Saturday, March 26, 2016

Maybelline Lash Sensational vs. Benefit Roller Lash Mascara

Maybelline Lash Sensational vs. Benefit Rollerlash Mascara

I recently repurchased an old favourite mascara (Benefit Roller Lash) and a new favourite mascara (Maybelline Lash Sensational) and realized that they seemed insanely similar to one another. I remember when these mascaras first released people were comparing them and saying that the Maybelline version was a cheaper dupe for Benefit's Roller Lash, but I wanted to test them out again and see which was better.

Maybelline Lash Sensational vs. Benefit Rollerlash Mascara

Maybelline Lash Sensational vs. Benefit Rollerlash Mascara

The first wand pictured is the Lash Sensational and the second is the Roller Lash. As you can see, they're both very similar! They're both rubberized and curved, but the Lash Sensational is almost double the thickness. I find that it picks up a lot more product at once than the Roller Lash, which means it can get clumpy very easily. It's not very buildable, and I usually apply only one coat, but this will obviously differ depending on your preference. If you don't mind the clumpy look, you could do two easily. With that being said, I LOVE this mascara. It curls my lashes like no other mascara I've ever used, and keeps the curl all day long. I never experience any flaking or smudging, and it isn't difficult to remove at the end of the day.

The Benefit Roller Lash is another great mascara, but considering it's three times the price of the Lash Sensational I would argue that it isn't as good. It's a lot more buildable, so you could do two or three coats without too many clumps, but it doesn't give me the dramatic curl that the Lash Sensational does. It also flakes and tends to smudge a little bit throughout the day. It isn't anything crazy, but if I'm spending $30 on a mascara, it needs to be perfect and this one isn't.

All in all, I would say both mascaras are great and worth trying, but if I had to repurchase one it would be Maybelline's Lash Sensational. I might even go so far as to say it's my favourite mascara of all time....

Have you tried either of these mascaras?


  1. I'm glad I read this because I got Roller Lash for Christmas and I do love it but I want one that will hold my curl for longer so I'll definitely pick this up now :) much more affordable too!

    Just Little Things xo

  2. I have not tried either one but now I feel like trying the Maybelline mascara. I love Maybelline mascara

    Nashia | MakeupandBeautyMayhem

  3. Great review - I personally love all Benefit mascaras! :D
    -Jenna <3
    Follow back? The Chic Cupcake


Reading your comments always brightens my day and I appreciate them all so so much! xoxo

© Melissa Bartlett | Beauty & Lifestyle. All rights reserved.
Blogger templates by pipdig